POWERTRAIN :
Except
for the Pulsar150 and the CBZ, all these bikes have different
engine and transmission configurations with unique ignition
mappings and head architecture. For starters the YBX125
has the least displacement of the lot at 123.7cc. Breathing
is via two valves and the unit develops 10.9bhp and 10.4Nm
of torque. An engine counter-balancer shaft is used to iron
out rogue vibrations. Transmission of power is via a four-speed
box which is the slickest of the lot. In terms of refinement,
the YBX loses out at the top end of the rev-range, with
vibrations rising to uncomfortable levels.
The
Kinetic GF125 can rightfully claim to be the technological
leader here,boasting a four-valve head to handle breathing
duties of the 125cc single but it loses all this with its
conventional carb when the industry is moving to CV instruments.
A digital CDI ignition system is used, mapped to adjust
timing relative to engine rpm for optimum Fuel
Efficiency. The unit develops a commendable 12bhp
though it develops just 9.81Nm of torque and that too at
a high-ish 8000rpm. The unit develops most of its power
at the upper reaches of the rev range and it is at this
level that vibrations from the unit become physically intolerable
while the decibels rise to deafening levels. Good for the
first month of riding but after time this lack of refinement
can become very painful. Starting is via an electric starter
that is part of the standard spec sheet while transmission
of power is via a five-speed box that disappoints in terms
of actuation and shift quality. In fact it has been getting
progressively worse and I have to employ the techniques
learnt in years of riding a Bullet to effect clean gear
shifts.
The CBZ derives power from a conventional 2-valve single
displacing 156.88cc. No surprise that her power output at
12.62bhp and torque rating at 12.3Nm is the highest of the
lot. Refinement of the engine isn't its strong point with
harsh vibes becoming prominent very early in the rev-range.
Transmission of power is via a five-speed box that doesn't
pose any headaches except when finding neutral. An electric
starter isn't offered even as an option.
Till recently the TVS Fiero boasted of the most technologically
advanced powerplant in the motorcycle business and this
unit yet impresses with its refinement and silky smooth
power delivery. Displacing 150cc, the unit develops 12bhp
and 10.5Nm of torque. A digital ignition system times the
spark to perfection while a constant velocity carburettor
ensures consistently precise metering of air-fuel mixture.
Transmission of power is via a slick four-speed gearbox,
though the engine really cries out for a fifth cog in the
'box.
The Pulsar 150 firmly establishes Bajaj engineers among
the forefront of engine gurus in the country, earlier the sole hunting ground of
the TVS boffins. The 143.9cc unit on the Pulsar boasts excellent
detailing in the design of the combustion chamber, intake
manifold length and airbox volume. A CV carburettor precisely
meters the air-fuel mixture and ensures crisp throttle responses
while a balancer shaft on the crankshaft works beautifully
to eliminate harsh vibes. The head architecture is conventional with two valves instead of a high-tech 4-valve
head that would make more power at the top end at the expense
of refinement and usable low-end torque. The ignition has
been optimised without need for a digital configuration.
Starting is via an optional electric starter. To make kickstarting
a breeze, a decompressor is built onto the camshaft. The
unit develops 11.82bhp while max torque is rated at 10.82Nm.
Transmission of power is via a five-speed box that is good
with nice positive actuation though not in the same league
as the Fiero or the YBX. Once in a while it does find a
false neutral between fourth and fifth gears though these
occurrences are very rare.
Performance :
Show
without go is meaningless. When we talk about Performance,
subjective evaluations get thrown out the window and objective
evaluations backed solidly by printouts from our Datron
data acquisition gear come into the picture. A day of back-to-back
testing of these bikes on the test track threw up some commendable
and some surprising Performances.
On the track the YBX125 performed commendably and actually
managed keep up with the larger engined bikes though it
was a foregone conclusion that the YBX would cross the finish
line dead last. The YBX took 7.8 seconds to touch 60kmph
and 15.3 seconds to hit 80kmph from a standing
start. These figures do not shame the YBX, considering that
the CBZ (which has a 1.72bhp and 33cc advantage) takes 0.1
second more to get to 60kmph though it is over a second
and a half quicker to 80kmph. The YBX clocked a max speed
of 102.8kmph.
Next
in line was the GF125, and expectations were running high
what with its first-for-India four-valve head, digital ignition
and a screamer motor. Initial acceleration of the GF is
mighty hot, taking 3.9 seconds to get to 40kmph and 7.5
seconds to get to 60kmph, quicker than the larger engined
Fiero and CBZ. However after 60kmph she rapidly loses ground
eventually hitting 80kmph in 14.8 seconds. The GF peaks
at a disappointing 96.4kmph at which point the vibrations
are so harsh that they could kill you if you wear a pacemaker.
The
Fiero took 7.6 seconds to get to 60kmph and 14.0 seconds
to get to 80kmph.These figures are neck and neck with the
CBZ that takes a slightly longer 7.9 seconds to get to 60kmph
after which she pulls away from the Fiero taking 13.7 seconds
to get to 80kmph, 0.3 second faster that the Fiero. The
CBZ has a higher top speed than the Fiero, 108.8kmph versus
103.8kmph for the Fiero. The reason why the CBZ beats the
Fiero at the top is because of the extra cog in the 'box.
However the Fiero's
trump card is the refinement of the motor that is superior
to the CBZ's and doesn't feel trashy when pulled right up
to the redline.
The Performance of the Pulsar
150 is simply amazing, pulling away right from the start
line to post a time of 6.3 seconds for the 60kmph sprint
and 12.1 seconds for the 80kmph sprint. This is a whole 2.4 seconds quicker than the next best CBZ,
this in spite of a 12.8cc and 0.8bhp disadvantage. Top speed
registered was a whopping 109.1kmph. If you notice the Pulsar
figures are better than what she delivered when we road
tested her last month, thanks to being completely run-in
and then tested on the track. |